A day to celebrate freedom and independence.
They are to be celebrated; right?
I wonder.
I seem to remember some sort of mixed messages about those two concepts. For some reason, throughout my history in the church those words seemed to evoke conflicting opinions.
Freedom
On the one hand we sang songs about glorious freedom and heard sermons and admonitions to live in the freedom that was offered through Jesus. On the other hand if someone claimed to be enjoying freedom, that claim was often met with skepticism and judgment and the implication that said person must actually be rebelling against something.
Independence
So then I wonder about independence - where there was also some sort of negative association - as if it were synonymous with rebellion - at least in terms of thinking and believing. If we were talking about financial independence, that was to be lauded. But spiritual independence? Not so much.
Or maybe call it intellectual independence. Sermons were preached and lessons were taught about how vital it is to learn to think for yourself as an antidote for bowing to peer pressure. That kind of independence was considered good, wise, commendable, noble, admirable. But when it came to questioning the things you had been taught, not so much. Nope, it was NOT commendable to question the rules that were handed down nor the elders who handed them.
...
Is it possible that independence is noble at times, but rebellious at other times? Am I the only one who wonders about this? Did anyone else receive mixed messages? Confusing "lessons" about freedom and independence?
...
I should learn to be independent, so that if my friends ever pressure me to do something dangerous or unwise, I can think for myself and be able to say "no" and to stand up to said peer pressure.
BUT if it was a church leader who was pressuring me to do something dangerous or destructive, then I must humbly submit to that pressure. To question traditional and legalistic rules and restrictions or to dare to stand up to someone in authority was deemed to be rebellious and dangerous.
So which is it? Is independence good or is it rebellious? Is freedom desirable or dangerous? When is it right to be free? When is it appropriate to be independent and when should we submit?
What about American independence? What about those founding fathers? Were they "right" in standing up to oppression and demanding to be free? What about other revolutions? Where is the line between independence and anarchy?
How about now? What does freedom mean in modern America? When conservatives complain that we are losing our freedoms, they certainly seem to mean something different than when a gay couple cries out for equality regarding their child's medical care. Can both sides be right? Can they even get along?
But those questions can't be answered in one blog post. And they may well be above my pay-grade. Whatever that means. I do not feel capable of solving the world's complex problems and I certainly am not smart enough to have the answers to how others should answer these questions.
But then I don't have to, do I? I am not responsible for the decisions of others. It's complex enough for me to figure out my own response and my own responsibility.
So what about it? What about me? How will I define freedom and independence? More importantly how will I choose when to be independent and when/where to fight for freedom?
...
A few conclusions at this moment in my journey of freedom:
- I am thankful for freedom and I celebrate it.
- I soberly accept the responsibility that comes with freedom and independence.
- I am wary of anyone who sets himself up as my authority and demands my submission.
- I realize that I am ultimately responsible to choose the authority figures and structures to whom I will submit; therefore, I seek to choose them wisely.
- I hope for wisdom to recognize injustice and oppression in my world and I pray for the courage to stand against them.
- I try to be alert to ways that I can provide and/or protect spaces of freedom for others.
...
I still wonder about many questions, but I can proceed with the things I know to do.